SUPERIOR PLUS ENERGY SERVICES INC

DBA: SPP

DOT# 157649 MC# 277904 DUNS# 13410444 Rochester, NY Authorized For-Hire / Private Property
(585) 328-3930 patwal@@superiorpropane.com 1870 Winton Road South Suite 200, Rochester NY 14618
2,030 power units 786 drivers
Strong
FRED Score 90.0 / 100
Moderate confidence
52 yrs history · 700 roadside inspections
Upside capped

FMCSA Live Status

Checking FMCSA…

Fleet & equipment

Power units
2,030
Drivers · CDL
786 · 763
Annual miles
22.4M unreliable
Type Own Term Trip Total
Trucks 403 123 0 526
Tractors 58 6 0 64
Trailers 111 45 0 156

Registration

Organization
CORPORATION
FMCSA Rating
Satisfactory (06-05-2000) · 26 yr old
Registered
06-01-1974 (52 yrs)
MCS-150 Update
09-30-2026 (Biennial Update)
FRED Score Date
Nov 07, 2026
Officer
JAMES (JAMIE) DEVENS
Officer
TOMMY MANION

Cargo

23.0
minimal risk
Liquids/Gases

Estimated from the commodity types reported to FMCSA, not from loss history or the true cargo mix.

Upside Withheld

Its risk relativity (0.41× similar fleets) would put it in Excellent; this rule holds it at Strong:

  • Held one band lower (interim): the filed fleet isn't corroborated roadside — see Exposure Unverified below

The downside is never capped.

Exposure Unverified

The expected crashes behind this grade assume the filed fleet of 2030 power units is real, but the roadside record corroborates little of it — 462 units seen in 24 months, 0.17 inspections per filed unit-year. The grade's relativity to class is unchanged; its confidence tier is cut to reflect the unverified exposure, and until the fleet is confirmed an Excellent grade shows as Strong and a Strong as Satisfactory. Verify the fleet size before relying on the crash expectation.

Mileage Unreliable

MCS-150 annual mileage appears too low for fleet size given observed activity. The per-100k-mile rate benchmarks on this page are excluded; the FRED grade does not use mileage (crash exposure is power-unit-years, violation exposure is inspection counts).

Expected crash rate is about half that of similar fleets.

Similar fleets: for-hire fleets of 500+ trucks with the same kind of operation, years in business and amount of road activity. Compared using its own crash record and roadside inspections.

This motor carrier 0.41×
ExcellentStrongSatisf.MarginalPoorCritical
▲ Similar fleets 1.0×
Expected crashes, next 12 months
13.3 vs 32.1 for similar fleets
Likely 7–21 crashes
This motor carrier
13.3
Similar fleets
32.1
Chance of a fatal crash, next 12 months
~30%
Below similar fleets.
What's driving the grade
Crash history
betterworse
Better than peers. 26 crashes on the FMCSA record in 24 months (about 13 a year), including 7 with injuries; similar fleets have about 32 a year. The grade counts 42 crashes in its 36-month scoring window, recent ones weighted most.
Roadside inspections
betterworse
Much better than peers. Unsafe-driving and hours-of-service violations 0.16×, violations 0.23× and out-of-service orders 0.29× the rate expected for its inspections. Together they move its crash estimate -34%.

Worth a closer look

From the FMCSA record. The grade already counts the safety items; insurance filings and links to other motor carriers are not in it.

  • Injury crashes
    7 crashes with 9 people hurt in 24 months.
    Ask: claim status and driver history for these crashes.
  • Driver qualification
    4 out-of-service violations against drivers: 4 no valid CDL (Jul 2025 – May 2026).
    Ask: driver qualification files and hiring standards.
  • Lights and brakes
    Lights are 67 of 256 violations (26%). Light or brake defects led to 24 out-of-service orders.
    Ask: the preventive-maintenance schedule and shop records.
  • Hazmat violations
    48 hazmat violations, 7 out of service.
  • Filed fleet not seen on the road
    Only 462 of the 2030 filed power units were seen at a roadside inspection in 24 months (700 inspections in all). The crash expectation behind the grade assumes all 2030 are running. Its grade is held one band lower until the fleet is confirmed.
    Ask: how many trucks are actually operating, with the vehicle schedule.
Strengths
  • Vehicle out-of-service rate 7.4% vs 22.3% national; driver 0.6% vs 6.7%.
  • No FMCSA BASIC alerts.
  • 75% of inspections found no violations.
Data flags
  • Dangerous driving: 2
  • Unreliable reported mileage
    The motor carrier's self-reported annual mileage (MCS-150) looks implausible, so exposure- and mileage-based figures may be distorted.
  • Estimated mileage
    No usable mileage was reported, so exposure was estimated from similar motor carriers. Mileage-based metrics here are approximate.

Track record

FMCSA record, Sep 2024 – Sep 2026 · grade scored on Sep 1, 2023 → Sep 30, 2026
Crashes
26
0 fatalities · 9 injuries · 0 tow-aways
Inspections
700
75% clean (no violations)
Vehicle out-of-service
7.4%
46 of 618
National avg 22.3%
Driver out-of-service
0.6%
4 of 698
National avg 6.7%
Violations
256
53 out-of-service
Inspections per quarter With an out-of-service order
Q4 '24: 109 inspections, 7 out of service 109 Q4 '24 Q1 '25: 89 inspections, 3 out of service 89 Q1 '25 Q2 '25: 69 inspections, 6 out of service 69 Q2 '25 Q3 '25: 80 inspections, 7 out of service 80 Q3 '25 Q4 '25: 98 inspections, 7 out of service 98 Q4 '25 Q1 '26: 104 inspections, 8 out of service 104 Q1 '26 Q2 '26: 92 inspections, 7 out of service 92 Q2 '26 Q3 '26: 55 inspections, 5 out of service 55 Q3 '26
Sep 25–30, 2024 isn't charted (too little of that quarter is on file); the 24-month totals include its 4 inspections.
vs 20 peer fleets
This motor carrierPeers
Crashes 0.006 0.016
Inspections 0.27 0.38
Violations 0.06 0.12
Critical violations 0.01 0.02

Yearly rates from the last 24 months. Peers: 500+ power units, minimal-risk cargo.

What they get cited for

256 violations · 24 months
  • Vehicle maintenance No alert
    187 · 42 OOS
    Lights 67 · Brakes 55 · Steering & suspension 12 · Tires 12 · Cargo securement 10 · 31 more
  • Unsafe driving No alert
    13 · 0 OOS
    Reckless / lane 4 · Speeding 4 · Phone use 2 · Seat belt 1 · Other 2
  • Driver fitness No alert
    6 · 4 OOS
    No valid CDL 4 · Medical certificate 2
  • Hours of service No alert
    2 · 0 OOS
    Logbook / ELD paperwork 1 · No log 1
  • Drugs & alcohol No alert
    0
  • Hazmat
    48 · 7 OOS
Out-of-service violations “No alert” = under FMCSA's BASIC intervention threshold

Violations by quarter

Tap a category to show or hide it
No violation trend data

Crashes

24 months
  • Aug
    20
    2026
    North Carolina
    Property damage only
    Daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median.
  • Jul
    28
    2026
    Connecticut
    Property damage only
    Daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median.
  • Jun
    30
    2026
    North Carolina
    Property damage only
    Daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median.
  • May
    20
    2026
    Michigan
    Property damage only
    Daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median.
  • Apr
    6
    2026
    Virginia
    Property damage only
    Daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median. Citation issued. Hazmat released.
  • Jan
    27
    2026
    Connecticut
    Property damage only
    Snow road, daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median.
  • Jan
    15
    2026
    Maine
    Property damage only
    Ice road, daylight, rain, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median.
  • Jan
    2
    2026
    New York
    Property damage only
    Daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median.

18 more in the FMCSA records below.

Insurance filed with FMCSA

FMCSA record through Nov 2, 2026
Today · live FMCSA check
Checking FMCSA…
Liability (BIPD)
$2,000,000 · Travelers Indemnity Co of Connecticut
on record since Feb 15, 2024 · FMCSA minimum $750,000 · no gap on FMCSA's record since Aug 1994
Cargo filing
not required by FMCSA (household-goods motor carriers only); the cargo policy is not on FMCSA's record
36 months to Nov 2, 2026
  • One liability insurer throughout
  • No gap in filed liability coverage while liability was required

Operating authority active (FMCSA's new registration system, status since Jan 14, 2020)

Who insures fleets like this →

FMCSA filings only, not a policy audit. Not part of the FRED grade. Wrong or out of date?

Where it happens

Loading map data…
Inspections by state
  • New York (HQ) 99
  • California 91
  • Virginia 65
  • New Hampshire 59
  • New Jersey 54
  • Pennsylvania 49
  • North Carolina 46
  • Georgia 38

14% of inspections were in its home state.