CITIE 1 TRUCKING LLC

DOT# 3693391 MC# 1289392 Garfield Heights, OH Authorized For-Hire
(216) 294-7451 citie1trucking@gmail.com 12914 Broadway Ave, Garfield Heights OH 44125
14 power units 8 drivers
BASIC Alerts: Hours-of-Service Driver Fitness
Marginal
FRED Score 32.7 / 100
Low confidence
5 yrs history · 26 roadside inspections
Current FMCSA Conditional rating (01-10-2026)

FMCSA Live Status

Checking FMCSA…

Fleet & equipment

Power units
14
Drivers · CDL
8 · 2
Annual miles
167k unreliable
Type Own Term Trip Total
Trucks 1 2 0 3
Tractors 0 4 0 4
Trailers 0 0 0 0

Registration

FMCSA Rating
Conditional (01-10-2026)
Registered
08-03-2021 (5 yrs)
MCS-150 Update
09-26-2026
FRED Score Date
Nov 07, 2026
Officer
KENYATTA VANCE-ANDERSON
Officer
TYRONE PARKER

Cargo

56.4
medium risk
Household Goods Metal: Sheets/Coils/Rolls General Freight Logs/Poles/Beams/Lumber Building Materials Fresh Produce Grain/Feed/Hay Dry Bulk Paper Products Construction Garbage/Refuse
High-Risk Cargo
General Freight, Household Goods

Note: "General Freight" is a catch-all; the actual cargo mix and its risk may differ.

Estimated from the commodity types reported to FMCSA, not from loss history or the true cargo mix.

Mileage Unreliable

MCS-150 annual mileage appears too low for fleet size given observed activity. The per-100k-mile rate benchmarks on this page are excluded; the FRED grade does not use mileage (crash exposure is power-unit-years, violation exposure is inspection counts).

Expected crash rate is probably higher than similar fleets (about a 70% chance), but the record is too thin to say by how much.

Similar fleets: for-hire fleets of 10–19 trucks with the same kind of operation, years in business and amount of road activity. Compared using its own crash record and roadside inspections.

This motor carrier 1.50×
ExcellentStrongSatisf.MarginalPoorCritical
▲ Similar fleets 1.0×
Expected crashes, next 12 months
0.9 vs 0.6 for similar fleets
Likely 0–2 crashes
This motor carrier
0.9
Similar fleets
0.6
Chance of a fatal crash, next 12 months
~2%
About 1.5× similar fleets.
What's driving the grade
Crash history
betterworse
Higher so far, not yet proven. 2 crashes on the FMCSA record in 24 months (about 1 a year), including 1 with injuries; similar fleets have about 0.6 a year. Too few crashes to be sure, so the grade counts its crash record as about 11% above typical. The grade counts 3 crashes in its 36-month scoring window, recent ones weighted most.
Roadside inspections
betterworse
Much worse than peers. Unsafe-driving and hours-of-service violations 5.27×, violations 2.37× and out-of-service orders 1.80× the rate expected for its inspections. Together they move its crash estimate +35%. It's inspected more often than most fleets its size.

Worth a closer look

From the FMCSA record. The grade already counts the safety items; insurance filings and links to other motor carriers are not in it.

  • FMCSA BASIC alerts
    Over FMCSA's intervention threshold in hours of service, driver fitness.
    Ask: any FMCSA warning letters and the corrective-action plan.
  • Injury crashes
    1 crash with 1 person hurt in 24 months.
    Ask: claim status and driver history for these crashes.
  • FMCSA suspension notice pending
    FMCSA served a notice on Oct 18, 2026: the operating authority will be suspended on Nov 17, 2026 unless the missing filing is restored. The notice does not say which filing. Not in the grade.
    Ask: which filing lapsed and whether it has been refiled.
  • Drivers put out of service
    12 out-of-service violations against drivers: 7 hours of service, 5 no valid CDL (Sep 2024 – Jul 2025).
    Ask: driver supervision and dispatch practices.
  • Driver out-of-service rate
    34.6% of driver inspections end out of service vs 6.7% nationally (9 of 26). Across all its inspections, out-of-service orders run 1.80× what's expected for where and how it's inspected.
  • Falsified logs
    2 false-log violations in 24 months.
    Ask: how hours are audited against ELD and fuel records.
Data flags
  • Current adverse FMCSA safety rating
    FMCSA currently rates this motor carrier Conditional or Unsatisfactory — a recent formal finding of safety-management deficiencies. Treat as a serious underwriting concern.
  • Dangerous driving: 2
  • Substance violations: 2
  • Unreliable reported mileage
    The motor carrier's self-reported annual mileage (MCS-150) looks implausible, so exposure- and mileage-based figures may be distorted.
  • Estimated mileage
    No usable mileage was reported, so exposure was estimated from similar motor carriers. Mileage-based metrics here are approximate.

Track record

FMCSA record, Sep 2024 – Aug 2026 · grade scored on Sep 1, 2023 → Sep 30, 2026
Crashes
2
0 fatalities · 1 injury · 0 tow-aways
Inspections
26
8% clean (no violations)
Vehicle out-of-service
25.0%
4 of 16
National avg 22.3%
Driver out-of-service
34.6%
9 of 26
National avg 6.7%
Violations
79
16 out-of-service
Inspections per quarter With an out-of-service order
Q4 '24: 4 inspections, 2 out of service 4 Q4 '24 Q1 '25: 1 inspections, 1 out of service 1 Q1 '25 Q2 '25: 8 inspections, 4 out of service 8 Q2 '25 Q3 '25: 9 inspections, 2 out of service 9 Q3 '25 Q4 '25: 1 inspections, 0 out of service 1 Q4 '25 Q1 '26: 1 inspections, 0 out of service 1 Q1 '26 Q2 '26: 0 inspections, 0 out of service 0 Q2 '26 Q3 '26: 1 inspections, 1 out of service 1 Q3 '26
Sep 25–30, 2024 isn't charted (too little of that quarter is on file); the 24-month totals include its 1 inspection.
vs 16,659 peer fleets
This motor carrierPeers
Crashes 0.071 0.031
Inspections 1.39 1.11
Violations 2.89 0.89
Critical violations 0.96 0.17

Yearly rates from the last 24 months. Peers: 10–19 power units, medium-risk cargo.

What they get cited for

79 violations · 24 months
  • Vehicle maintenance No alert
    35 · 4 OOS
    Lights 15 · Brakes 6 · Cargo securement 2 · Wheels & hubs 2 · Tires 1 · 9 more
  • Hours of service FMCSA alert
    32 · 7 OOS
    Over hours limit 16 · Logbook / ELD paperwork 11 · No log 3 · False log 2
  • Unsafe driving No alert
    7 · 0 OOS
    Reckless / lane 3 · Speeding 3 · Phone use 1
  • Driver fitness FMCSA alert
    5 · 5 OOS
    No valid CDL 5
  • Drugs & alcohol No alert
    0
Out-of-service violations “No alert” = under FMCSA's BASIC intervention threshold

Violations by quarter

Tap a category to show or hide it
No violation trend data

Crashes

24 months
  • Aug
    31
    2026
    Ohio
    Property damage only
    Daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median. Citation issued.
  • Jul
    7
    2025
    Ohio
    Injury · 1 person hurt
    Daylight, two-way trafficway divided unprotected median. Citation issued.

Insurance filed with FMCSA

FMCSA record through Nov 2, 2026
Today · live FMCSA check
Checking FMCSA…
Liability (BIPD)
$750,000 · Universal Casualty Risk Retention Group, Inc (risk retention group)
on record since Nov 17, 2025 · FMCSA minimum $750,000 · no gap on FMCSA's record since Aug 2023
Cargo filing
not required by FMCSA (household-goods motor carriers only); the cargo policy is not on FMCSA's record
36 months to Nov 2, 2026
  • 3 liability insurers on FMCSA's record, 2 changes: ACCREDITED SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY → UNIVERSAL CASUALTY RISK RETENTION GROUP, INC (Nov 2024); EVERSPAN INDEMNITY INSURANCE COMPANY → ACCREDITED SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY (Aug 2024)
  • 3 cancellation notices filed by insurers; 3 took effect (the last Nov 14, 2025, replaced 3 days later)
  • No gap in filed liability coverage while liability was required
Authority
  • FMCSA notice served Oct 18, 2026: the operating authority will be suspended on Nov 17, 2026 unless the missing filing is restored (the notice does not say which filing). FMCSA's new registration system launched May 14, 2026 and has recorded some insurance suspensions and requirement changes in error; confirm with the insurer or motor carrier before acting.
  • FMCSA notices resolved in time: 2

Operating authority active (FMCSA's new registration system, status since Aug 30, 2023)

Who insures fleets like this →

FMCSA filings only, not a policy audit. Not part of the FRED grade. Wrong or out of date?

Where it happens

Loading map data…
Inspections by state
  • Pennsylvania 4
  • New Jersey 3
  • Ohio (HQ) 3
  • Maryland 2
  • Michigan 2
  • New York 2
  • South Carolina 2
  • Connecticut 1

12% of inspections were in its home state.